A conservative religious couple, Lexi Love and Parker Ambrose, are not supposed to have sex because they're not married yet. However, their friend Allison informs them that there is another loophole they can use instead; anal sex. This leads to the shy, clumsy couple trying out anal- focused foreplay and anal sex for the first time and loving it. A husband, Isiah Maxwell, and wife, Jayden Cole, are using Isiah's ex, Nicole Kit, as a surrogate, and she is staying with them as they prepare for the clinical insemination process. Although they are all on good terms, Jayden admits to having had fears about Isiah ultimately cheating on her with his old flame. Isiah assures her that that won't happen and they settle into bed. After Jayden drifts off, the mischievious surrogate sneaks into the room and seduces Isiah, horny for his seed the good old- fashioned way.